Welcome Renewing Your Mind Broadcast Tabletalk Magazine Conferences Publishing Store

Cosmic Treason

Right Now Counts Forever, January 2007

by R.C. Sproul

The question, “What is sin?” is raised in the Westminster Shorter Catechism.  The answer provided to this catechetical question is simply this, “Sin is any want of conformity to or transgression of the law of God.”

Let us examine some of the elements of this catechetical response.  In the first instance, sin is identified as some kind of want or lack.  In the middle ages, Christian theologians tried to define evil or sin in terms of privation (privatio) or negation (negatio). In these terms, evil or sin was defined by its lack of conformity to goodness. The negative terminology associated with sin may be seen in biblical words such as disobedience, godlessness, or immorality.  In all of these terms, we see the negative being stressed. Further illustrations would include words such as dishonor, antichrist, and others.

However, to gain a complete view of sin, we have to see that it involves more than a negation of the good, or more than a simple lack of virtue. We may be inclined to think that sin, if defined exclusively in negative terms, is merely an illusion. But the ravages of sin point dramatically to the reality of its power, which reality can never be explained away by appeals to illusion. The reformers added to the idea of privatio the notion of actuality or activity, so that evil is seen then in terms of the phrase, “privatio actuosa.” This stresses the active character of sin. In the catechism, sin is defined not only as a want of conformity but an actual act of transgression, an action that involves an overstepping or violation of a standard.

In order to grasp the meaning of sin, we cannot define it apart from its relationship to law.  It is God’s law that determines what sin is.  Since it is God’s law that defines the nature of sin, we are left to face the dreadful consequences of our disobedience to that law.  Just as sin is defined by a lack of conformity to the Law, or transgression of the Law, the only antidote for that transgression is obedience to the Law.  If we possess such obedience to the Law of God, we are in no danger of the judgment of God.  

The only righteousness that meets the requirements of the Law is the righteousness of Christ.  It is only by imputation of that righteousness that the sinner can ever possess the righteousness of the Law.  This is critical for our understanding in this day where the imputation of the righteousness of Christ is so widely under attack.  If we abandon the notion of the righteousness of Christ, we have no hope, because the Law is never negotiated by God.  As long as the Law exists, we are exposed to its judgment unless our sin is covered by the righteousness of the Law.  The only covering that we can possess of that righteousness is that which comes to us from active obedience of Christ, who Himself fulfilled every jot and tittle of the Law.  His fulfilling of the Law in Himself is a vicarious activity by which He achieves the reward that comes with such obedience.  He does this not for Himself, but for His people.  It is the background of this imputed righteousness, this rescue from the condemnation of the Law, this salvation from the ravages of sin that is the backdrop for the Christian’s sanctification, in which we are to mortify that sin that remains in us, since Christ has died for our sin.

Dr. R.C. Sproul is minister of preaching and teaching at Saint Andrew’s Chapel in Sanford, Florida, and he is the author of the book A Taste of Heaven.
AddThis Feed Button